This article is available (with images) in PDF format (922Kb)
My Magellan handheld GPS says Latitude 27º09'00" South, Longitude
109º20'20" West. Yes that's right, South. In the middle of
the South Pacific is an island approximately 2200 miles west of Chile,
2300 miles east of Tahiti, and 4993 miles as the crow flies from the
D. Wellman Surveying office in Eugene, Oregon, U.S.A. The place is
Easter Island. It's a rather long way from home to do a laser-scanning
survey,
but the circumstances merited the expedition to the Polynesian island
of Rapa Nui, or in Spanish, Isla de Pascua.
Rapa Nui is not a place that one gets to easily. If you don't want to
go by boat, there is only one commercial option by air, and that's
with the very accommodating LanChile airlines and their luxurious Boeing
767.
You can depart from Santiago, Chile, or from Papeete, Tahiti. Flights
run twice a week. This type of schedule does not conform to the conventional
Monday-through-Friday business week, but the thought of a layover in
Tahiti while waiting for the next flight out added an exotic flair
to the work assignment. The round-trip ordeal of transporting a mountain
of high-tech equipment (with the word “laser” on the packing
label), computers, survey gear, and crew members through three major
airports in three different countries, while fumbling with different
languages, currencies, customs officials, freight offices, baggage
clerks, bellhops, hotel rooms and taxis, is not for the faint of heart.
That
is a whole story in itself. Yet, let us suffice it to say, we made
it!
Rapa Nui History
Present theory and legend suggest that indigenous Polynesian settlers
arrived as early as 400 to 800 A.D. Legend suggests that King Hotu
Matu'a brought 300 settlers from the West, somewhere in eastern Polynesia.
Scholars' research and the isolation of the island, indicates that
the inhabitants developed a culture free from outside intervention
until Europeans showed up on the scene. The most intriguing aspect
of the culture, and certainly the interest of many present-day tourists,
are the ever present stone statues, called moai, found throughout
the island. The first written record was by the Dutch explorer Jacob
Roggeveen,
who “discovered” the island on Easter Sunday, 1722, and
mentioned the moai and the inhabitants. He wondered then how the statues
could have been erected without the timbers and strong ropes that were
used in his modern world. My favorite Pacific Ocean explorer, Captain
James Cook, went in search of the island in 1774 for a place to “rest
his men” after searching for Antarctica. Cook found that some
of the moai had been “toppled from their platforms.” Visits
by other explorers, as early as 1825, recount that all the moai had
been toppled.
Starting in 1805 and continuing through the mid 1860's, slave traders
raided the islands to supply workers for the Peruvian guano mines.
The native population was decimated by slavery as well as the introduction
of smallpox and tuberculosis. Less than one hundred direct descendants
of the original population remained on Rapa Nui. Thus, a validated
oral
history of the islands was also lost. Rapa Nui was one of the first
Polynesian cultures to have a written language, and is evidenced as such
by the
discovery of the rongorongo. These scribed tablets display specialized
characters, yet those who could read them were lost with the rest.
With no understandable written language, and the break in the chain of
oral
history, much of Rapa Nui and its incredible past remains a mystery.
Why these colossal stone heads and temples? How were they moved and
erected? Why were they toppled? What caused “the birdman cult” to
become predominant?
Rapa Nui Today
Fifteen miles long and 7.2 miles wide, Rapa Nui has one main town—Hanga
Roa. Mataveri Airport was expanded by the U.S. Air Force in 1966, and
by NASA in 1986 to provide an emergency landing place for the space
shuttle. A bustling combination of Chilean and Rapa Nui residents number
about
2500. A fascinating mix of Polynesian and Spanish cultures is seen
daily in the small shops, modest homes, and quaint hotels. Dogs and
horses
can be seen on the cobblestone streets, and there are lively soccer
games in the park overlooking the town beach on Sundays. Ever present
are the
silent, stone carvings. The languages are Rapa Nui and Spanish, the
money is the Chilean peso, and the government is that of a Chilean
colony.
Since 1935 a large part of the island has been designated as a Chilean
National Park. Parque Nacional Rapa Nui nearly encompasses the island
and includes many of the special features along coastal and inland areas.
It is open at all times for a modest fee to the tourist and visitor.
It is possible to tour on your own, but to enjoy the treasures to the
fullest, a guide is recommended.
We were lucky. Our guides were our clients, the accomplished archeologist
Dr. Terry Hunt, and his students from the University of Hawaii Department
of Anthropology. A local Rapa Nui committee called the Consejo
de Monumentos Rapa Nui is charged with the protection and oversight of the cultural
resources on the island. The consejo issues permits to scientists such
as Dr. Hunt after approval of proposals for research and study. Dr. Hunt's
permitted study area was along the south central coast and therefore
was our permitted area for this project. However, with other proper approvals
gained by Dr. Hunt, we could expand our project to include some other
interesting cultural features. Of course the moai are the main attraction
to tourists and researchers alike, but an incredible amount of interest
on an international scale takes place in many different scientific disciplines.
The success of this project could have profound effects in the scientific
and academic worlds.
The request for our services as surveyors was based on the University
of Hawaii Department of Anthropology's need to evaluate the collection
and presentation of 3D digital models of moai. Up until this time standard
procedures such as photogrammetry, calipers, and tape measures were used
to provide measurements for the study of the statues, ahu (ancient temples),
and related artifacts. 3D scanning technology, such as Cyra Technologies'
Cyrax 2500 can provide the required accuracy and completeness of data
collection of cultural resource treasures such as the moai. A benefit
of the technology is the ability to obtain data without touching the
artifact. This fact alone is important in gathering dimensional data
information on priceless cultural resources and artifacts.
An Intricate Mosaic of Rocks
Being one of only a few companies in the Pacific Northwest that were
using 3D survey grade scanning technology at the time, we proposed
a joint effort for this pilot project. We teamed up and pooled resources
with the Honolulu office of Geo-InSight International Inc. to scan
the statues on Rapa Nui. The project objective was to provide an
assortment of 3D scanned “point clouds” for our client
to evaluate. Our mission was to provide scanning services and generate
enough detailed
information to demonstrate the advantages of scanning technology
in the field of cultural resources data collection.
Upon our arrival our client took us to the largest and most complex
ruin in his permitted area. Before us lay an intricate mosaic of rocks,
upturned moai, toppled moai topknot hats, and remnants of the ahu upon
which the moai stood—some parts in good shape, some parts in
disarray. The crew made a quick huddle, came up with a plan, and proceeded
to scan
away for the rest of the day. The sun was shining, and while computers
and scanners processed the data, we seized the opportunity to take
in the fantastic scenery of Rapa Nui at our job site by the sea. It
was
a sight we never tired of during our time on Rapa Nui.
While scanning, one crew established a control survey around the perimeter
of the site with a key point at the top of the ruins. The non-invasive
scanning technology helped maintain respect for the ahu, which hold religious
meaning to the Rapa Nui people. Our control survey was to be used by
the scientists at a later date to coordinate their aerial survey work
with our scanning control, as well as with surrounding project sites.
Without having done their GPS survey control prior to our arrival, we
assigned temporary local project coordinates to our points.
The complexity of the project required that we use multiple scans registered
together to form one cohesive 3D model. This would allow the 3D model
to have a complete scan from many angles, thus covering as many surfaces
of the site as possible. As the scanning progressed across the project,
high resolution targets were set out to tie our earlier scans to the
work in progress. These precise, and highly reflective targets allow
each of the multiple scans to be registered together, much like overlapping
aerial photography uses control points.
We used a combination of methods for the registration on this project.
Within the Cyra Cyclone software is a target scanning and registration
routine. Precise real world, or project coordinates of the targets, do
not need to be known for the scans to be registered to each other. The
arbitrary coordinate system created by the scanner becomes the coordinate
system for the model. The software automatically registers multiple scans
together by matching the naming convention applied to each target by
the scanner operator. However, we elected to tie as many of the targets
as possible with our reflectorless total station, a Leica TCR703, calculating
and noting our project coordinates of each target. This methodology essentially
tells the scanner the coordinates of specified targets, restrains the
registration reduction to those coordinates, then allows for a redundant
analysis in Cyra's least squares registration routine.
Infectious Enthusiasm
The project covered two days of scanning. Each days' target coordinates
were entered into a separate registration routine and designated
as the “home scan.” An analysis of the residuals of the
registration process allows the operator to cast out redundant outlier
target registration
combinations which degrade the validity of the solution. Once the
registration is completed, each point generated by the scanner has
an assigned project
coordinate. The entire 3D model is then ready for inspection, surface
modeling, detailed measurements, or export to third party software
uses for any number of different applications.
Product specifications of the Cyrax system are published as 1 sigma
single point position accuracy of ±6mm within the 1.5 meter
to 50 meter range. Previous experience with the scanner suggests accuracies
better than this at nearly twice the distance. We have found that high
angles of incidence and shiny surfaces affect accuracy the most dramatically.
Our subject survey error budgets were well within this range. There
would
be no viable way of checking our accuracy resolution due to the nature
of the rock, erosion and degradation of the stone, and varied shapes
of the objects. We felt that the truest representation would best be
generated by dense overlapping scans. In this manner multiple points
could then be statistically modeled into a more true-to-form shape
of the subject piece by using third party surfacing software. Scans
for
this trial were at a nominal 6 x 6 mm spacing. The amount of data collected,
and the representation of the point cloud exceeded the client's expectations.
The ability to collect such a comprehensive data set far exceeded the
archeologist's efforts to date.
That evening, and most evenings after that, some students headed to
the disco to enjoy the night life, while others would gather around and
watch as we registered the scans together and showed off our day's work.
They asked questions about services we could provide, data accuracy,
technology applications, and applicability of 3D scanning to other projects
they were working on. These sessions proved to be a rewarding and challenging
aspect of the project for us.
Scanning enthusiasm became infectious, not only within our group, but
with other professionals on the island as well. Application ideas were
growing in number. The value of the completeness of the “point
cloud” data was being realized. The wish list of projects increased;
ours included some scans of moai that were standing up.
Our wish was granted on Sunday by Francisco Torres, Acting Director
of the local museum, Museo Antropologico Sebastian Englert. A moai stands
in front of the museum. Torres had been watching our scanning process
all week and felt it would be a great opportunity to get a scan of the
moai for the museum. The deal was made and we were scanning by noon.
Another valued scan for the scientists to evaluate was that of the impressive
petroglyphs at Orango. The petroglyphs are carved on a rock outcrop
located at the terminus of a precarious, knife-edged ridge—1,000 feet high—that
separates the caldera of an ancient volcano from the Pacific Ocean. The
objective of this portion of the project was to evaluate the use of scanning
to “digitally preserve” the petroglyphs. The Consejo de
Monumentos, also in charge of preserving Rapa Nui treasures, is concerned
about the
degradation of the petroglyphs in such an exposed location, as well
as the eminent destruction if the ridge tumbles into the ocean.
A day off was highly encouraged in order to tour the rest of the island
and gain an appreciation of all there was to offer. Scattered throughout
the island are the ruins of hundreds of ahu, remains of houses, petroglyphs,
caves, standing moai, fallen moai, and more. Perhaps the most impressive
sight is that of Rano Raraku—the quarry. It is here that hundreds
of statues, in all stages of completion, dot the sides of another giant
extinct volcano. Most moai are 20 feet tall or larger and weigh up
to 80 tons. The largest is 69 feet long, and would have been taller,
but
was never finished. How many people must have worked here and for how
long? How were the moai moved off the side of this mountain and transported
up to 10 miles away? The scene is both eerie and fantastic as one walks
amongst the colossal heads. It seems as if one Friday afternoon the
foreman blew the whistle and told everyone not to come back on Monday.
The Best of Professions
Another interesting stop was that of Anakena Beach. It is in fact one
of the few beaches on this rugged volcanic island. This is the spot
where it was believed King Hotu Matu'a first landed his canoes of settlers.
Nearby is the temple Ahu Nau Nau. This restored ahu and well preserved
moai was covered with sand until the 1978 reconstruction. The sand
beach, ahu, moai, and planted palm forest presents another classic
Easter Island scene.
On our last evening Dr. Hunt reminded us all of how very few professionals
get an opportunity to work on Rapa Nui and it's mysteries. To be allowed
such an opportunity was both a professional and personal honor. I can
think of few other careers that provide as much enjoyment and allow us,
as professional surveyors, to use our skills and equipment to assist
other professionals with their efforts. Add in a little flavorful travel,
some new and unique environments, intriguing clients, and a few technical
hurdles, and you end up with a rewarding surveying career. This project
certainly was one to be remembered, but I hope not the last of an anticipated
long list of adventures to come.